You’ve received three managed IT proposals. One quotes $95 per user monthly. Another wants $145. The third is $180. All three promise “proactive monitoring,” “help desk support,” and “security management.”
The descriptions sound identical. The pricing differs by nearly 90%. And you’re left wondering what you’re actually paying for, and more importantly, what you’re not getting at the lower price point.
For Toronto SMBs evaluating managed IT providers, pricing opacity creates impossible comparisons. The per-user number tells you almost nothing about service substance, operational reality, or whether you’ll actually get the protection and support your business needs.
Why Managed IT Pricing Varies by 40% for “The Same Service”
Identical service descriptions mask completely different operational realities. When three providers all claim to offer “24/7 monitoring and support,” they’re rarely describing the same thing.
The $95 provider might mean automated alerts reviewed once daily during business hours, with after-hours support requiring additional fees. The $145 provider could include genuine 24/7 SOC monitoring with human analysts triaging threats in real time. The $180 provider might add strategic quarterly reviews and compliance documentation that the others exclude entirely.
Here’s what typically sits behind identical marketing language:
Monitoring depth: Basic uptime checks versus comprehensive endpoint visibility, network traffic analysis, and security event correlation
Response protocols: Email ticket submission versus phone support, versus direct access to named engineers who know your environment
Expertise levels: Tier 1 help desk technicians handling password resets versus senior engineers managing complex infrastructure
Security integration: Basic antivirus versus layered endpoint protection, email security, firewall management, and threat hunting
The price difference isn’t arbitrary markup. It reflects fundamentally different service models that deliver different business outcomes.
The Per-User Model (And What It Actually Includes)
Most managed IT providers price on a per-user-per-month basis, but what that actually covers varies dramatically by provider and tier.
At $75-$100 per user, expect:
- Help desk support during business hours (email/phone)
- Basic endpoint monitoring and patch management
- Reactive issue resolution within standard SLA
- Limited network monitoring
- Basic antivirus/antimalware
At $100-$150 per user, expect:
- Extended or 24/7 help desk coverage
- Proactive monitoring with automated remediation
- Enhanced security tools (EDR, email filtering)
- Network performance monitoring
- Monthly or quarterly business reviews
- Basic compliance documentation support
At $150-$200+ per user, expect:
- Dedicated account management and vCIO services
- Comprehensive security stack (SIEM, MDR/XDR)
- Strategic IT planning and roadmapping
- Priority response with guaranteed SLAs
- Compliance readiness (SOC2, ISO prep)
- Advanced services like penetration testing
But even within these ranges, specific inclusions vary. One provider’s $120 tier might include backup management while another’s excludes it entirely. Understanding the service matrix matters more than the headline number.
The Services That Look Included But Aren’t
This is where pricing transparency breaks down and surprise invoicing begins. Services that sound like core managed IT but almost always cost extra:
Project work: Network upgrades, server migrations, software rollouts, infrastructure redesign—anything beyond “keeping current systems running” typically bills separately at hourly or project rates
Hardware: Endpoints, servers, network equipment—some providers lease equipment as part of service bundles, most expect you to purchase separately
Software licensing: Microsoft 365, security tools, backup solutions—providers manage these but rarely include licensing costs in per-user pricing
Security add-ons: Penetration testing, security awareness training, incident response retainers—often presented as “available” but priced separately
Compliance services: SOC2 audits, policy documentation, controls implementation—strategic work that sits outside operational management
Onboarding: Initial network assessment, documentation creation, systems standardization—may require separate implementation fee
The $95 provider who seems cheaper might exclude backup management, security tools, and after-hours support that the $145 provider includes. Suddenly the “expensive” option costs less when you add what’s missing.
Before comparing prices, get explicit confirmation: what’s in base pricing, what’s optional add-on, what’s separate project work, and what’s your responsibility to provide.
What You’re Actually Paying For (Beyond the Technical Services)
Managed IT pricing isn’t just buying technical tasks. It’s purchasing business outcomes that most SMB owners significantly undervalue until they’re missing.
Risk transfer: You’re no longer the one responsible when systems fail, security incidents occur, or compliance audits reveal gaps. The provider owns resolution, carries liability, and absorbs the cost of their mistakes.
Operational predictability: Fixed monthly costs replace unpredictable break-fix bills, emergency rates, and crisis spending. You can budget accurately instead of hoping nothing breaks.
Strategic guidance: vCIO services provide the IT leadership most SMBs can’t afford to hire. Technology decisions align with business objectives instead of happening reactively under pressure.
Reduced cognitive load: You stop being the integration point between technical silos, the mediator between vendors, and the person who has to understand every IT decision’s implications.
Proactive problem prevention: Issues get identified and resolved before they impact users, not after employees are already complaining and productivity is lost.
Compliance readiness: Frameworks, documentation, and controls get built systematically instead of scrambled together when a customer asks or an auditor shows up.
The business that pays $180 per user for comprehensive managed services plus integrated security isn’t overpaying compared to the one spending $95 for basic support. They’re buying operational maturity, risk protection, and strategic capability that the cheaper option simply doesn’t provide.
When Lower Pricing Signals Future Problems
Artificially low managed IT pricing creates the exact problems it’s supposed to prevent. When providers undercut market rates, they’re either cutting corners on service delivery or planning to recover costs through add-ons and overages.
Watch for these red flags in below-market proposals:
- Response times measured in days, not hours
- No after-hours or emergency support included
- “Monitoring” that’s really just automated alerts with no human analysis
- Security services limited to basic antivirus
- Help desk staffed by tier 1 technicians with no senior escalation path
- No strategic planning, business reviews, or proactive recommendations
- Surprise project charges for routine infrastructure maintenance
- Exclusions for backup management, compliance support, or vendor coordination
The provider charging $85 per user isn’t offering you a deal. They’re offering you understaffed support, reactive-only service, and basic tooling that leaves your business exposed to the ransomware, compliance failures, and operational chaos that managed services should prevent.
You’ll end up paying the difference, just through emergency response fees, breach remediation costs, lost productivity, and eventually switching providers after discovering they can’t deliver what your business needs.
The Hidden Costs of Your Current Approach
Before dismissing managed services as expensive, calculate what your current approach actually costs.
Most SMBs are already spending on:
- Fractional or full-time IT staff salaries ($60K-$90K+ for someone capable)
- Break-fix IT support charged at emergency rates when things fail
- Software licensing scattered across departments with no optimization
- Security tools purchased reactively without integration or management
- Compliance consultants hired when customers require certifications
- Downtime impact measured in lost revenue and damaged reputation
- Leadership time spent managing IT vendors, making technical decisions, and firefighting issues
Add it up honestly. A 30-person business paying $150 per user ($4,500 monthly, $54K annually) for comprehensive managed services often spends more than that on their current fragmented approach, just without the predictability, expertise, or accountability that managed services provide.
The question isn’t whether managed IT costs money. It’s whether the alternative costs more while delivering less protection, less strategic value, and more operational chaos.
Evaluating Proposals Based on Operational Reality
Price per user is a starting point, not a decision criterion. Before signing, get specific answers that reveal what you’re actually buying:
Ask about response protocols: What’s the guaranteed response time for critical issues? Who actually answers when you call? Do you get a dedicated team or whoever’s available? What constitutes after-hours support versus business hours?
Clarify monitoring scope: What systems get monitored? How often? Who reviews alerts and decides what’s actionable? What’s the escalation path when issues are detected?
Define security inclusion: Which security tools are included in base pricing? What’s managed versus just recommended? How do updates, threat response, and incident investigation work?
Understand exclusions: What services require separate project quotes? What’s your responsibility to provide or purchase? Where do overages occur?
Evaluate strategic support: Do you get regular business reviews? Technology planning? Compliance guidance? Or purely reactive support when things break?
The provider who can answer these questions specifically, with documented SLAs and clear service definitions, is offering real managed services. The one who speaks in generalities and promises everything is setting you up for disappointment, surprise costs, and eventually a painful provider transition.
Your business deserves transparency on what you’re paying for, confidence that it will actually be delivered, and accountability when gaps emerge. Managed IT pricing should reflect operational substance, not marketing promises.
Learn More About Managed Service Models
Want to understand how different managed IT service tiers align with specific business needs and risk profiles? Explore resources on building the right technology foundation for your growth stage and industry requirements.
